Replies to the comments to the manuscript ‘Advanced error diagnostics of the CMAQ and Chimere modelling
ثبت نشده
چکیده
In this work authors pursue their efforts in devising more sophisticated methods for error analysis in air quality models. In the light of experience gained during the AQMEIIs phases, they analyze results for ozone simulation for North America (CMAQ) and Europe (CHIMERE). Given that a statistical analysis of model results can only be the first step toward a more-in-depth diagnosis of model deficiencies (it is difficult at this level to disentangle the impact of NOx/VOC chemistry, radiation, boundary layer dynamics and biogenic emissions, dry deposition, etc.), they report some interesting results which would be help in orienting modelers during model development or gaining confidence in using model predictions.
منابع مشابه
Replies to the comments to the manuscript ‘Advanced error diagnostics of the CMAQ and Chimere modelling
General Comment: This study pursues to outline the evaluation methods applied during the three phases of the AQMEII activity in view of building an evaluation strategy. Annual simulations of the WRF-CMAQ and IFSChimere are evaluated, as well as runs with perturbed emissions or boundary conditions or ozone deposition. The analysis focuses on ozone simulations over selected European and North Ame...
متن کاملInteractive comment on “Advanced error diagnostics of the CMAQ and Chimere modelling systems within the AQMEII3 model evaluation
Given that a statistical analysis of model results can only be the first step toward a more-in-depth diagnosis of model deficiencies (it is difficult at this level to disentangle the impact of NOx/VOC chemistry, radiation, boundary layer dynamics and biogenic emissions, dry deposition, etc.), they report some interesting results which would be help in orienting modelers during model development...
متن کاملCaliope: an operational air quality forecasting system for the Iberian Peninsula, Balearic Islands and Canary Islands – first annual evaluation and ongoing developments
The Caliope project funded by the Spanish Ministry of the Environment establishes an air quality forecasting system for Spain to increase the knowledge on transport and dynamics of pollutants in Spain, to assure the accomplishment of legislation and to inform the population about the levels of pollutants, topics in which the European Commission has shown a great concern. The present contributio...
متن کاملارزیابی میزان دقت داوران یکی از مجلات علمی پژوهشی فارسی زبان در تشخیص اصلاحات مورد نیاز یک مقاله علمی ارسالی؛ سال 1389
Background and Objectives: Final corrections on a manuscript sent for publication in a scientific journal are suggested by reviewers. So this qualifies the paper with the least errors for publication. The present study aimed to assess the Persian language peer reviewers' comments on a manuscript sent to an Iranian Scientific Journal (journal of Rafsanjan university of medical sciences), 2010....
متن کاملEvaluation of the Effective Electrospinning Parameters Controlling Kefiran Nanofibers Diameter Using Modelling Artificial Neural Networks
Objective(s): This paper investigates the validity of Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) model in the prediction of electrospun kefiran nanofibers diameter using 4 effective parameters involved in electrospinning process. Polymer concentration, applied voltage, flow rate and nozzle to collector distance were used as variable parameters to design various sets of electrospinning ex...
متن کامل